An executor can buy property from the estate they’re administering, but only under strict legal conditions including explicit authority in the will, informed consent from all adult beneficiaries with independent legal advice, or court approval, as the “rule against self-dealing” makes any such purchase automatically voidable by beneficiaries regardless of fairness or price paid, even years after the transaction.
While specific statistics on executor property purchases are limited, the legal framework surrounding these transactions reveals their complexity and potential risks. The landmark case Tito v Waddell (No.2) established that executor self-dealing transactions are “voidable by any beneficiary however fair the transaction,” with no time limit for challenges. Legal professionals report that approximately 15-20% of family disputes arise from executor conflicts of interest, with property purchases being among the most contentious issues. The rule against self-dealing exists because executors owe fiduciary duties to beneficiaries, meaning they must act solely in beneficiaries’ best interests rather than their own financial advantage.
Table of Contents
Can an Executor Buy Property from the Estate?
The rule against self-dealing forms the cornerstone of executor property purchase restrictions. This legal principle recognises an inherent conflict of interest when executors wish to buy estate assets: as executor, they must maximise the estate’s value for beneficiaries, but as purchaser, they want the lowest possible price.
This fundamental conflict explains why the law treats executor purchases with such suspicion. The fiduciary duty requires executors to act solely in beneficiaries’ best interests, putting the estate’s welfare above their personal desires. When an executor wants to purchase property, these duties directly conflict with their personal interests.
| Purchase Method | Requirements | Beneficiary Protection | Risk Level for Executor |
|---|---|---|---|
| Will Authority | Express exclusion of self-dealing rule | Limited – depends on will wording | Low if clearly worded |
| Informed Consent | All adult beneficiaries with independent legal advice | High – full disclosure required | Medium – consent can be challenged |
| Court Approval | Application demonstrating benefit to estate | Maximum – court oversight | Low – court protection |
| Third Party Purchase | Sell to unrelated buyer who then sells to executor | None – circumvention is prohibited | Very High – still voidable |
This table illustrates the different approaches executors might consider when wishing to purchase estate property, along with the associated protections and risks. As demonstrated, there’s no risk-free method for executors to purchase estate property without following proper legal procedures.
The most secure approach involves court approval, though this requires demonstrating that the purchase serves beneficiaries’ interests rather than the executor’s convenience. Even seemingly protective measures like third-party intermediaries don’t shield executors from the self-dealing rule’s scope.
What Happens If an Executor Buys Property Without Permission?
When an executor purchases estate property without following proper procedures, beneficiaries can void the transaction at any time in the future, regardless of whether they suffered financial loss or initially agreed to the sale.
The legal consequences are severe and long-lasting:
Any beneficiary can challenge the purchase, even decades later
No time limit exists for bringing such challenges
The transaction can be set aside regardless of fair market value
Executors may face personal liability for any losses
Other beneficiaries don’t need to prove harm or unfairness
The case of Tito v Waddell (No.2) established this principle clearly, stating that executor purchases are voidable “however fair the transaction.” This means even if the executor paid full market value and all beneficiaries initially approved, the purchase remains vulnerable to challenge.
This uncertainty explains why many legal professionals advise executors to avoid purchasing estate property altogether, recommending alternative arrangements that don’t create ongoing legal vulnerability.
Can Multiple Executors Agree to Let One Buy Property?
When multiple executors are appointed, they cannot simply agree among themselves to allow one executor to purchase estate property. The rule against self-dealing applies equally to all executors, regardless of whether their co-executors approve the transaction.
The self-dealing rule protects beneficiaries, not other executors, so executor consensus doesn’t override the prohibition. All executors owe the same fiduciary duties to beneficiaries, meaning they cannot authorise transactions that benefit one executor at the potential expense of the estate.
For multiple executor situations involving property purchases, the same protections must be followed:
Express authority in the will
Informed consent from all beneficiaries
Court approval for the transaction
The purchasing executor should also consider stepping down from their role for this specific transaction, though this must happen before they take any administrative actions regarding the estate.
How Does Informed Consent Work for Executor Property Purchases?
Informed consent represents one of the most complex methods for permitting executor property purchases, requiring much more than simple beneficiary agreement. The process demands rigorous procedures to ensure beneficiaries truly understand the implications of their consent.
Requirements for valid informed consent include:
All beneficiaries must be over 18 years old with full mental capacity
Each beneficiary must receive independent legal advice
Full disclosure of all relevant facts about the property and transaction
Professional valuation to establish fair market value
Understanding of their right to challenge the transaction
Formal documentation of the consent process
The consent must be freely given without coercion or undue influence. Simply having beneficiaries sign a document stating they agree to the sale isn’t sufficient – they must demonstrate genuine understanding of the legal implications and their rights.
This process can be expensive and time-consuming, often involving separate solicitors for each beneficiary to ensure independence. Many families find the complexity makes alternative solutions more practical.
Reddit Insights: Real Executor Property Purchase Experiences
Online forums reveal common misunderstandings about executor property purchases that can lead to serious legal problems. One particularly concerning case involved an executor who expanded the estate by purchasing additional property, taking on debt without beneficiary knowledge or consent.
The executor used estate rental income to secure a mortgage for buying adjacent land, believing this would increase the estate’s value. When market conditions changed and the additional property lost value, beneficiaries questioned whether the executor had overstepped their authority by actively expanding rather than just administering the estate.
At Property Saviour, we’ve observed that many executor property problems stem from good intentions combined with poor understanding of legal limitations. The desire to “keep property in the family” or “maximise estate value” can lead executors into complex legal territory that creates more problems than solutions.
Another Reddit case highlighted the emotional complications that arise when executors live in estate property while trying to purchase it. Family dynamics often deteriorate when some beneficiaries perceive the executor as benefiting unfairly from their position, even when proper procedures are followed.
We’ve found that many families benefit from clear, professional advice early in the process. When executors understand the complexity and risks involved in purchasing estate property, they often choose simpler alternatives that achieve their goals without ongoing legal vulnerability.
The Will Authority Exception: When Property Purchase is Pre-Approved
Some wills include clauses that explicitly permit executors to purchase estate property, potentially bypassing the self-dealing rule. However, the wording must be exceptionally clear and unequivocal to provide meaningful protection.
Courts scrutinise will authority claims carefully, looking for:
Express language excluding the self-dealing rule
Specific reference to property purchase permissions
Clear indication that the testator understood the implications
Unambiguous wording that couldn’t be interpreted differently
Vague language like “my executor may deal with my property as they see fit” won’t provide adequate protection. The will must specifically address the conflict of interest and demonstrate the testator’s informed decision to permit such transactions.
Even with clear will authority, executors should still consider obtaining professional valuations and maintaining transparent communication with beneficiaries to demonstrate fair dealing and reduce the likelihood of future challenges.
Court Approval: The Safest Route for Executor Property Purchases
Seeking court approval represents the most secure method for executors wishing to purchase estate property, though it requires demonstrating that the transaction benefits the estate rather than serving the executor’s convenience.
Courts consider several factors when evaluating applications:
Whether the proposed purchase price reflects fair market value
If the executor has obtained independent professional valuations
Whether alternative buyers have been sought
If the purchase serves a legitimate estate purpose
Whether beneficiaries support or oppose the application
The court approval process involves formal applications, evidence gathering, and potentially contested hearings if beneficiaries object. While expensive and time-consuming, successful court approval provides strong protection against future challenges.
Eunice from Worcester faced this situation when she wanted to purchase her late mother’s cottage where she’d been caring for her mother for five years. “I’d put my life on hold to care for Mum, and the cottage felt like home, but as executor I knew the legal complications,” she explains. After exploring the court approval process and its costs, Eunice decided the complexity wasn’t worth it. She contacted Property Saviour instead, who purchased the property at fair market value, allowing Eunice to buy a different property nearby without the legal complications. If you’re facing similar dilemmas about executor property purchases, we understand how emotionally charged these decisions become and can provide straightforward alternatives that achieve your goals without legal risk.
Alternative Solutions When Executors Want Estate Property
Given the complexity and risks associated with executor property purchases, many families benefit from exploring alternative approaches that achieve similar goals without legal complications.
Practical alternatives include:
Renouncing Executor Role: Stepping down before taking any administrative actions allows purchase as a regular beneficiary
Professional Executor Appointment: Engaging a neutral executor to handle the sale removes conflicts of interest
Delayed Purchase: Completing estate administration first, then purchasing from beneficiaries as individuals
Third-Party Purchase Solutions: Working with property buying companies that can facilitate swift, fair transactions
When Mandy from Woking wanted to purchase her father’s workshop property to continue his business, the legal complications seemed overwhelming. “Dad appointed me as executor because he trusted me, but buying the workshop seemed impossible with all the self-dealing rules,” she recalls. Property Saviour provided a solution that worked for everyone – we purchased the workshop at fair market value, eliminating the legal complications while allowing Mandy to negotiate a separate rental agreement to continue the business operations.
These alternative approaches often prove simpler, faster, and less expensive than attempting to navigate the self-dealing exceptions, while achieving the executor’s ultimate goals without ongoing legal vulnerability.
Why Choose Us Over Estate Agents for Your Inherited Property Sale?
Being an executor or inheriting property shouldn’t feel like a punishment, but that’s exactly what happens when you get caught up with traditional estate agents. They’ll take your money upfront, stick a board outside, and then spend months telling you why your property isn’t selling – the market’s tough, it needs work, the price is wrong, buyers are difficult. Meanwhile, you’re paying insurance, council tax, and maintenance on an empty property while nothing actually happens.
Here’s what makes us different: we actually solve your problem instead of just talking about it. When Property Saviour makes you an offer, that’s it – we’re committed. No chains, no mortgage approvals to fall through, no surveys that suddenly reveal “problems” that knock thousands off the price. We buy properties in any condition, which means you don’t need to spend your inheritance fixing someone else’s house before you can sell it.
Estate agents work on commission – they only get paid if they can find someone willing and able to buy your property. We’re not agents, we’re buyers. We have the cash ready and can complete in days, not months. No marketing period, no viewings with strangers tramping through your family home, no waiting around wondering if today’s the day someone might make an offer.
The emotional side matters too. We know that inherited property often comes with complicated feelings, family dynamics, and pressure to make decisions while you’re still grieving. That’s why we don’t play games with pricing or drag things out unnecessarily. Fair offer, quick completion, job done.
Had enough of the uncertainty? Stop letting estate agents waste your time and money. Give us a call and find out what it’s like to work with people who actually want to buy your property, not just talk about maybe possibly finding someone else who might.
Sell With Certainty & Speed
Property Saviour Price Promise
- The price we’ll offer is the price that you will receive with no hidden deductions.
- Be careful with ‘cash buyers’ who require a valuation needed for a mortgage or bridging loan.
- These valuations or surveys result in delays and price reductions later on.
- We are cash buyers. There are no surveys.
- We always provide proof of funds with every formal offer issued.
We'll Pay £1,500 Towards Your Legal Fees
- No long exclusivity agreement to sign because we are the buyers.
- You are welcome to use your own solicitor.
- If you don’t have one, we can ask our solicitors for recommendations.
- We share our solicitor’s details and issue a Memorandum of Sale.
Sell With Certainty & Speed
- Our approach is transparent and ethical, which is why sellers trust us.
- 100% Discretion guaranteed.
- If you have another buyer, you can put us in a contracts race to see who completes first.
- Complete in 10 days or at a timescale that works for you. You are in control.
